In This Section

Air Quality An Introduction Archeology BLM Castle Valley Climate Climate Change Colorado River Data Documents Dolores River Economy Education Emery County Energy EPA Events Food Forests Fracking Geology GIS Grand County Graphics Ground-Water and Geology Health History: Human and Natural Housing Invasives Maps Mining Moab Monticello NEPA News & Opinion Non-Profits NPS Oil & Gas Oil (Tar) Sands Oil Shale (Kerogen) Permaculture Photos Potash Presentations Public Notices San Juan County SITLA Soils Uranium USGS Utah Waste Water Water Planning Watershed Watershed Tools Wildlife Wildlife Conservation

Oil (Tar) Sands

Oil shale and tar sands remains a speculative industry in the arid lands of the Colorado Plateau. A general lack of water is why the industry will never be viable. Even if alternative chemical washes are used to separate bitumen from sand, for example, it still requires 1.5 to 2 barrels of water to refine a single barrel of synthetic crude. What this extraction will accomplish is physical damage to the Colorado River watershed, which supplies culinary water to nearly 30 million people. It will also create more CO2 in the atmosphere, which is the #1 killer of the Rocky Mountain snowpack, which provides 85% of the Colorado River's total annual water supply. Our watershed needs investors to create a reliable energy supply that will heal the water supply of the Colorado River, not destroy it.

Read this article about strip mining tar sands in Grand County

To SUBMIT A LETTER of concern to Utah Division of Oil, Gas and Mining click here

Article with talking points

____________________________________

INVENTORY OF TAR SAND DEPOSITS IN UTAH

State Land (SITLA)

• 141,020 State Trust acres on which tar sands are known or expected.
• 52,887 State Trust acres under lease for tar sands
• A typical lease lasts 10-years
• Only a very small part of the above acres could be surface mined
• US Oil Sands Lease with SITLA
• US Oil Sands Contract Report. SITLA.

Federal Lands (BLM)

• NOTE: there are no tar sands in Colorado or Wyoming.
• 2008 - Total identified is 430,686 acres
• 2012 - The proposed preferred alternative identifies 91,045 acres
• RECORD OF DECISION (Issued March 22, 2013)

____________________________________

ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD OF UTAH DIVISION OF OIL, GAS & MINING (UDOGM)

• UDOGM permit files (complete)
  
• Username and password is: ogmguest
• UDOGM Board Notes and Dockets

ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD OF PROPOSED STRIP MINING @ PR SPRINGS

US Oil Sands (Utah) Inc., (formally Earth Energy Resources)

• Docket of PR Springs litigation
• UDOGM docket for PR Springs litigation
• DWQ docket for PR Springs litigation
• Earth Energy Resources @ PR Springs for large mining & alternate
• Earth Energy Resources @ PR Spings for small mining & alternate
• 2007 - EER Mining Plan PR Springs in Grand and Uintah County
• 2009 - EER Mining Plan PR Springs in Grand and Uintah County
• 2009 - Presentation by Earth Energy Resources
• 2010 - EA for public comment on water well for PR Springs. BLM
• Public Notice: EER proposal for large scale mining of tar sands at PR Springs. Comments are due: 30 days after March 23, 2010.
• Grand County Council Comments
• 2010 - Initial Comments by Non-Profit Groups
• 2011 - Notice of Intent for exploratory drilling of bitumen deposits at PR Springs by Oil Sands USA
• Math - The PR Springs project will provide the nation with 6 hours of oil consumption.
• Analysis Spreadsheet (xls)
• Ophus Process - What we know about the citrus based processing chemical. MSDA reports.
• Patent Application; Lemon Terpenes; Akzo Surfacant 01; Akzo Surfacant 02;

ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD OF UTAH DIVISION OF WATER RIGHTS @ PR SPRINGS (State Engineer)

Water Right for US Oil Sands 49-2274 (a33805)

• Drill logs for 5 water production wells
• Administrative record @ Utah Division of the State Engineer
• Water right 41-3523 (Uintah County Water Conservancy District)
• Request For Extension Of Time To File Proof Of Beneficial Use
• Photos of destructive road and well pad activities

Other water rights (adjacent to proposed mine @ 4.5 gallons per minute)

• Water right 49-1567
• Water Right 49-122
• (Docs)

Additional water well information (state and federal)

• Willow Watershed 1406006 (Lower Green/Desolation Canyon).EPA.
• Willow Watershed Water Resources Links. USGS.
• EPA groundwater summary of Uinta Basin
• Map: Water well and pipeline
• Map: Topo of PR Springs
• Proposed water well. Division of Water Rights.
• 2010 - Comments on BLM's EA for water well at PR Springs. Living Rivers.
• Map of well site
• Satellite image of well pad for PR Springs mine
• FOIA - BLM Water Right-of-Way @ PR Springs mine
  

ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD UTAH DIVISION OF WATER QUALITY (DWQ) for PR SPRINGS

• Consolidated Initial Record as of January 2012
• DWQ website archive
• March 2011 - Appeal to Utah Division of Environmental Quality
• November 2011 - Order on motion to dismiss denied
• May 2012 - Transcript of Hearing Vol. 1 & Vol. 2.

TRANSCRIPTS OF HEARINGS FOR PR SPRINGS STRIP MINING OPERATION

• Informal hearing transcription of 7/27/10
• Compilation of reference materials
• 2011- Prepared testimony from expert witnesses: Elliott Lips & Charles Norris 01 & Charles Norris 02
• 2011 - Transcript of Formal UDOGM Hearing of Feb. 2011.
• 2012 - Transcript of expert witness William Johnson
• May 2012 - Transcript of DWQ Hearing Vol. 1 & Vol. 2.

ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION ADMINISTRATION (EPA)

Air Quality at Proposed PR Springs Mine

• Part One; Part Two; Part Three; Part Four; Part Five;
• Air Reources and Chemical Processing
• NSPS Subpart Ja
• 2010 - Fact sheet on ozone standards

____________________________________

ASPHALT RIDGE MINING OPERATIONS (near Vernal, Utah)

• Map - Asphalt Ridge Projects.
• Brief History of Asphalt Ridge Development.

Crown Asphalt Ridge (CAR) Korea Technology Industry of America (Defunct)

• Website - JAM Industrial, Inc. (Tar sands demonstration project that ended in bankruptcy).
• 2004 - Study Demonstration Process Bitumen Utah Tar Sand. Society of Petroleum Engineers.
• CAR Google Earth

 

• CAR - Department of Water Quality (DWQ)
• CAR - Public Notice Public Notice
• CAR - Application Letter. 2012.
• CAR - Application. 2012.
• CAR - Application Appendix A Lab Report. 2012.
• CAR - Application Appendix B Well Logs. 2012.
• CAR - Application Attachments. 2012.
• CAR - Statement Of Basis. 2012.
• Comments - Western Resource Advocates and Living Rivers. 2012.
  
• Response - To WRA and LR. 2012.

MCW Energy Group @ Asphalt Ridge

• MCW Energy - GoogleEarth.
• MCW Energy - Public Notice.
• MCW Energy - DWQ Application.
• MCW Energy - Construction Permit.
• MCW Energy - Statement of Basis.

____________________________________

BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT

• 1983 - Uinta Basin Synfuels Development, FInal Environmental Impact Statement. www.riversimulator.org/Pubs/OSTS/Ref/BLMsynfuelsFEIS1983.pdf
• 1983 - Utah Combined Hydrocarbon, Regional Draft Environmental Impact Statement. www.riversimulator.org/Pubs/OSTS/Ref/BLMregionalDEIS1983a.pdf
• 1984 - Utah Combined Hydrocarbon, Regional Final Environmental Impact Statement. www.riversimulator.org/Pubs/OSTS/Ref/BLMregionalFEIS1984.pdf
• 1984 - Book Cliffs Resource Management Plan, Final Environmental Impact Statement. www.riversimulator.org/Pubs/OSTS/Ref/BLMveranalRMP1984.pdf
• 1984 - Air quality assessment for the Environmental Impact Statement on the Federal Oil Shale Management Program.www.riversimulator.org/Pubs/OSTS/Ref/BLMAirQualityOSTS1984.pdf
• 1985 - PR Spring Combined Hydrocarbon Lease Conversion Draft Environmental Impact Statement. www.riversimulator.org/Pubs/OSTS/Ref/BLMprSpringsDEIS1985.pdf
• 1985 - PR Spring Hydrocarbon Lease Conversion Final Environmental Impact Statement. www.riversimulator.org/Pubs/OSTS/Ref/BLMprSpringsFEIS1985.pdf
• 1990 - Winter Ridge Wilderness Study Area. www.riversimulator.org/Pubs/OSTS/Ref/BLMwinterRidgeWSA1990.pdf
• 1999 - Utah Wilderness Inventory. www.riversimulator.org/Pubs/OSTS/Ref/BLMwilderness1999.pdf
• 2013 - Oil Shale & Tar Sands, Programatic Environmental Impact Statement: Official web site.ostseis.anl.gov/documents/index.cfm
• RECORD OF DECISION (Issued March 22, 2013)

 

Paving Seep Ridge Road in Uintah County

• Environmental Assessment
  

2008 Oil Shale & Tar Sands Programmatic EIS

• Home Page
• Federal Notice
• Environmental Impact Statement
• Record of Decision
• Additional Information
• Tar Sands: Basic Information
• Oil Shale: Basic Information
• Endangered Species List
• Comments of California Attorney General

____________________________________

CORPORATE WEBSITES

• NEW: Company Profiles
  

• Nevtah Capital Management
• US Oil Sands formerly Earth Energy Resources
• 2007 - EER Mining Plan PR Springs in Grand and Uintah County
• 2009 - EER Mining Plan PR Springs in Grand and Uintah County
• 2009 - Presentation by Earth Energy Resources
• Korea Technology Industry of America
• Presentation: Mining in Uintah County
• Temple Mountain Energy
• Wentworth Energy (Asphalt Ridge tar sands)
• American Sands Energy Corp

____________________________________

DOCUMENTS

• 2007 - Analysis of Utah Tar Sands. Baxter.
• 2008 - History of Tar Sands in North America. Congressional Research Service.
• 2010 - Energy-Water Nexus: Better Understanding of Water Resources. GAO.
  
• 2010 - American Tar Sands. Willliams.
• 2010 - Water Availability for Tar Sands and Oil Shale. Keiter.

____________________________________

ENDANGERED AND THREATENED SPECIES

• Critical Habitat Designation. USFWS.
• Mexican-spotted owl
• Greater sage grouse
• Graham's Penstemon (Photo) (Recent news) (Aid to identify)
• Screen of endangered species at Red Leaf Resources
• Map 01 & Map 02: endangered species @ Red Leaf Resources
• Sage grouse brood habitat at PR Springs
• Critical Habitat Map. The Wilderness Society.

____________________________________

GEOLOGY

Oil Shale and Tar Sands web page. Utah Geologic Survey.
Tar Sands Bibliography (2009). UGS.
USGS publications library

• 2008 - Oil shale and tar sands Programmatic EIS. BLM.
• 2008 - Holocene Debris Flows on the Colorado Plateau. Webb.
• 1996 - Tar Sands Resources Uinta Basin. Blackett.
• 1992 - Hydrocarbons along proposed Book Cliffs Highway. UGS.
• 1984 - Characteristics of PR Springs Tar Sands. Dana.
• 1984 - Economic Potential of PR Springs Tar Sands. UGS.
• 1983 - Potential Impacts on Hydrology from Tar Sands Industry. USGS.
• 1980 - PR Springs Tar Sands. UGS; Dahm.
• 1980 - Characteristics of PR Springs Tar Sand Deposits. DOE.
• 1980 - Characterization of Utah Bitumen. BoM.
• 1980 - Properties of Utah Tar Sands. BoM.
• 1979 - Geology Oil Impregnated Sandstone Utah. UGS; Campbell.
• 1975 - Hydrologic Reconnaisance of Southern Uinta Basin, Utah and Colorado. Price & Miller.
• 1975 - Mineral Resources of Uintah Ouray Reservation. USGS.
• 1971 - Grand County Tar Sands. UGS; Gwynn.
• 1970 - PR Springs Tar Sands. UGS; Byrd.
• 1966 - PR Springs Tar Sands. Open File Report; UGS.
• 1966 - PR Springs stratigraphic column of tar sand deposits
• 1964 - Bituminous Sandstone Uinta Basin. Covington.

Geologic Bibliography

• Uinta Basin Geology

____________________________________

LEGAL DOCUMENTS

• 2009 - Letter from Western Resource Advocates.
• Petitioners withdraw with prejudice
• PR Springs Settlement. SUWA, Sierra Club, Western Resource Advocates.
• Comments on Air Quality from Oil and Gas Development in Dixie Nat. Forest
• 2010 - Montana Environmental Information Center v BLM
• 2010 - Mexican spotted owl critical habitat decision
• 2010 - History of Mexican spotted owl appeal

____________________________________

MAPS & GIS

• BLM PEIS: Tri-state deposits
• Uinta Basin

Google Earth

• Tar sand deposits 01. Data from BLM PEIS.
• Tar sand deposits 02. Data from BLM PEIS.
• Satellite image of well pad for PR Springs mine

PR Springs

• Map of 1966
• Tar sand saturation map of 1966
• 1966 - PR Springs stratigraphic column of tar sand deposits
• Stratigraphic column Section 27 (Monument Ridge Road Junction)
• Location of spings
• Map: Topo of PR Springs
• Map: Proposed mining operations @ PR Springs
• Location of tar sand deposits in Uinta Basin

SITLA

• Oil shale resource ownership
• Parcels in Grand County (14.9%; about 550 sq. miles)
• US Oil Sands Lease with SITLA
• US Oil Sands Contract Report. SITLA.

University of Utah

• Interactive Map

Other

• Critical Habitat Map. The Wilderness Society.
• Map - Where tar sand oil is refined
• Map: PR Springs water well and pipeline
• Map: Topo of PR Springs
• Map: Proposed mining operations @ PR Springs

____________________________________

NEWS

• 6/15/10 - Wildflower vs. Oil Shale. Salt Lake Weekly.
• 11/30/10 - GAO: More research needed on oil shale, water
  
• 9/17/2007 - Tar sands, oil shale. Energy Bulletin.
• 3/17/2010 - First US Tar Sands to Break Ground in Utah.
• 3/18/10 - Tar sand industry comes to eastern Utah.
• 3/24/10 - Decision on wildflower protection expected soon. Assoc. Press.
• 3/28/10 - Company seeks first U.S. oil sands project in Utah. SL Tribune.
• 3/29/10 - Sage Grouse will play role in Western energy development.Marten Law.
• 4/29/10 - Salazar aide - Oil shale not ready for prime time

____________________________________

NON-PROFIT ORGANIZATIONS

• Document archive. Western Resource Advocates.
• Fossil Foolishness. Western Resource Advocates
• Northern Rockies Rising Tide
• CERES Report on Oil Shale/Water Nexus.
• Tar Sands: Feeling the climate crisis. FOE Europe.
• Dirty Oil. Greenpeace.
• 2011 - Between a Rock and a Dry Place: The Impact of Oil Shale Development and Climate Change on the Colorado River Basin Water Supply. NRDC

____________________________________

PHOTOS

• Baseline Map: Drill Test Sites PR Springs
• Book Cliffs Divide Road Grand County; Reduced
• Camp One; Reduced
• Camp Two; Reduced
• Drill Pads; Reduced
• East Canyon Grand County Approach; Reduced
• Equipment Yard; Reduced
• Landscapes; Reduced
• Neighboring Gas Well; Reduced
• Pit; Reduced
• Processing Site; Reduced
• Products; Reduced
• PRsprings; Reduced
• Water Well Site One; Reduced
• Earth Energy Resources @ PR Springs, June 2010
• Earth Energy Resources test pit: #1; #2; #3; #4;
• BLM PEIS photos

Aerial Photos

• Aerial photos of East Tavaputs Plateau. Large file. Includes operations by US Oil Sands and Red Leaf Resources; areas of chained trees; wilderness and roadless areas.
• Tar sand mining boundary of PR Spring 01 (blue line is Grand & Uintah border)
• Tar sand mining boundary of PR Spring 02

Satellite Images

• Satellite image of well pad for PR Springs mine

____________________________________

TRADE ASSOCIATIONS

• White Paper. Utah Mining Association.

____________________________________

UNIVERSITY

• 2007 - Utah Tar Sands: Worth the Energy?
• 2009 - Oil Shale Report. University of Colorado at Boulder.
• University of Utah ICSE Digital Repository
• 2009 - Western US Tar Sands Conference

____________________________________

USGS

• Oil shale and tar sands interactive web page (excellent resource)
  
• 1995 - Surface disturbances and the role of accelerating erosion. Belnap.
• Graphic: tar sand deposits in the USA.

____________________________________

UTAH GOVERNMENT

• Home page: Utah Oil, Gas & Mining
• Public records: Utah Oil, Gas & Mining. (Username and password is ogmguest)
• FTP Site. Utah Oil Gas & Mining
• PR Springs water right 01 and 02. Utah Division of Water Rights.
• 1980 - An Assessment of Oil Shale and Tar Sands Development
• 2009 - Bibliography of tar sand deposits & map. Utah Geological Survey.
• 2009 - Approval of PR Springs strip mine for tar sand. UDOGM.
  2010 - Notice regarding PR Springs Mine to Grand County Council. UDOGM.

____________________________________

VIDEO

• Fossil Foolishness. Western Resource Advocates.
• A film by Leslie Iwerks
• The Tar Sands Blow
• Tar Sands, Canadian Broadcasting Corporation
• Red Leaf Resources. EcoFLight.

____________________________________

WILDLIFE
Southest Utah (includes East Tavaputs Plateau)

• Amphibian Inventory. DWR.
• Avian Inventory. DWR.
• Bison Reintroduction. DWR.
• Black Bears. DWR
• Ecosystem Evaluation. DWR.
• Mammal Inventory. DWR.
• Reptile Inventory. DWR.
• Bison Herd Unit Management Plan
• Inventory of birds